PLAUTUS MENAECHMI PDF SERIES

Each encounter with a misidentified twin destabilizes the status quo and provides valuable insight into Roman domestic and social relationships. A gluttonous parasite, manipulative courtesan, shrewish wife, crotchety father-in-law, bumbling cook, saucy handmaid, quack doctor, and band of thugs comprise the colourful cast of characters.

PLAUTUS MENAECHMI PDF SERIES

Menaechmi is a tale of identical twin brothers who are separated as young children and reconnect as adults following a series of misadventures due to mistaken identity. This new volume in the Bloomsbury Ancient Comedy Companions series is perfect for students coming to one of Plautus' most whimsical, provocative, and influential plays for the first time, and a useful first point of reference for scholars less familiar with Roman comedy. вЂњ Simillimi ed insania nei Menaechmi,вЂќ Eos 72, 87вЂ“94.This new volume in the Bloomsbury Ancient Comedy Companions series is perfect for students coming to one of Plautus' most whimsical, provocative, and influential plays for the first time, and a useful first point of reference for scholars. The myth of mental illness: Foundations of a theory of personal conduct. Follia e malattie mentali nella medicina dellвЂ™etГ Romana. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 84, 442вЂ“452. On pseudoscience in science, logic in remission, and psychiatric diagnosis: a critique of RosenhanвЂ™s вЂOn being sane in insane placesвЂ™. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 84, 462вЂ“474. The contextual nature of psychiatric diagnosis. вЂњPsychiatric diagnosis.вЂќ Correspondence section in Science, new series 180(4084), 356+358+360вЂ“369. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina. The physician in ancient comedy (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Plautus: With an English translation (Vol. вЂњInside the battle to define mental illnessвЂќ, Wired Magazine. Tontini (Eds.), Lecturae plautinae sarsinates X: Menaechmi (pp. Mania e medicina nei Menaechmi e in altri testi. (Since the wordplay on melas works better in Greek than in Latin, I assume it derives thence and not, as so often elsewhere, from the wellspring of PlautusвЂ™ imagination.)Д«urzacchini, G.

Baffled, Menaechmus naturally takes the two words to mean literally вЂњwhiteвЂќ and вЂњblackвЂќ-like Crayola colors as it were. Moreover, вЂњdarkвЂќ wine in Latin is usually nigrum, not atrum (Fantham 2007, 2011). Latin album and atrum do mean вЂњclearвЂќ and вЂњmuddy,вЂќ but very rarely-only one attestation apiece, and both very late (Apicius 1.6 and Palladius 11.14.9 respectively).

This ambiguity explains why Menaechmus finds the question so bizarre. Indeed we might well translate the two adjectives as вЂњclearвЂќ and вЂњmuddyвЂќ respectively. For him, вЂњdarkвЂќ ( melas) wine is usually muddy ( pachys). In his commentary on HippocratesвЂ™ passage Galen (AD 129- c.200/c.216) points out that color implies taste, clarity or consistency ( systasis), odor, and strength. Incidentally, color is not really the sole issue. These observations decisively refute an older suggestion that the doctorвЂ™s questions relate to the regularity of MenaechmusвЂ™ bowel movements (as cited in Gratwick 1993, ad loc.). Implicitly the doctor is afraid Menaechmus has been drinking dark wine, since according to Ps.-Aristotle ( Problemata 30.1, 954a ) it produces the same symptoms as does black bile in melancholic individuals. Had he gotten a chance to ask it, the doctorвЂ™s next question would have been, вЂњHave you been drinking the other kind today?вЂќ At the end of chapter 10 of On Regimen in Acute Diseases Hippocrates states, вЂњWhite and dark wines ( leukos te kai melas oinos) are both strong, but if a person makes an unaccustomed ( para to ethos) switch to one from the other, they will alter many things in his body.вЂќ The repetition in MenaechmusвЂ™ reply of soleam (= Greek to ethos), вЂњnormally,вЂќ indicates that the doctor is inquiring whether Menaechmus customarily drinks вЂњwhiteвЂќ (Greek leukos ~ album) or вЂњdarkвЂќ wine (Greek melas ~ atrum) ( HVA part 3 KГјhn 15.626вЂ“30 = CMG 5.91 Helmreich). As Rankin ( 1972) has noticed, Hippocratic teaching held that a sudden change in dietary habits could produce malign effects on the body (p. With this much-misunderstood question the doctor is probing two points derived from Hippocratic medical inquiry of the times:Д®xplicitly he is inquiring about a sudden change in drinking habits.

Plautus menaechmi pdf